Stop locking horns - start seeking solutions!

Just click the “Schedule Mediation” button at top right to review our availability calendar.

In-person mediation available in Bay, Escambia, Okaloosa, Santa Rosa, and Walton Counties.

Virtual mediation available throughout the State of Florida.

Patrick K. McCarthy, Esq.

Florida Supreme Court Certified Circuit Court Mediator

I am a believer in the mediation process. I believe sensible resolutions for most legal disputes can be reached if the parties focus on the future and not the past, honestly assess the strengths and weaknesses of their case, and effectively communicate with one another. Rarely do parties regret reaching a settlement in mediation and wish they had incurred the additional cost and stress of continued litigation. An effective mediator can help parties overcome communication barriers so that good faith negotiation of settlement possibilities can occur. As your mediator my objective is to ensure all settlement options are exhaustively explored with the goal being to reach a settlement agreement that allows all parties to put litigation behind them.

I approach mediation from a unique perspective. Like most mediators, I am an attorney who has litigated all types of civil disputes.  Unlike most mediators, however, I have spent many years starting and operating several types of businesses that from time to time became involved in legal disputes. Not only have I participated in litigation and mediation as an attorney, I have also participated in both as a party. I know from experience what it is like to be deposed, called as a witness at trial, negotiate in mediations, sit through a jury trial, carry the stress and uncertainty that goes along with litigation, and pay legal fees for months on end. Having seen litigation from various angles, I can provide parties with a unique perspective to help them best assess the risks and benefits of reaching a mediated settlement versus going to trial.

My professional background is varied which allows me to relate to parties on a different level than your typical mediator. Since graduating law school at the University of South Carolina in 1997, I’ve handled various types of civil cases in state and federal courts including: products liability and mass tort litigation; business, commercial, and contract disputes; real estate, upland boundary, and riparian boundary disputes; landlord tenant disputes; real estate financing litigation; construction litigation; and civil rights and police misconduct litigation. Additionally, I’ve served as general counsel to various companies and represented individuals in contract negotiations, business formation, business capitalization, business acquisition and sale, and intellectual property. Outside active legal practice I’ve co-founded and operated several businesses including software start-ups, real estate sales brokerages, and many real estate development companies. The bulk of these business ventures involved large scale commercial, multi-use, and multi-family real estate developments in which I led land acquisition, due diligence, regulatory approval, site and building design, financing, marketing and sales, and construction management.

I look forward to helping you and your clients find satisfactory solutions to resolve disputes.

For a full bio of Patrick, click here

Mediations can be scheduled for half day or full day. Half day mediations are scheduled for 4 hours maximum (unless the parties desire to continue beyond 4 hours and the mediator does not have another mediation scheduled). Full day mediations start in the morning and will continue until resolution or impasse.

To schedule a mediation, select the appropriate option below for in person or virtual and half day or full day. Then select the date for your mediation and provide the requested information. We will contact you to confirm.

Schedule Your Mediation

  • “Mediation is a process whereby a neutral and impartial third person acts to encourage and facilitate the resolution of a dispute without prescribing what it should be. It is an informal and non-adversarial process intended to help disputing parties reach a mutually acceptable agreement.” Florida Rule for Certified and Court-Appointed Mediators 10.210. Mediation seeks to achieve a voluntary resolution to disputes that is crafted by the parties rather than dictated by a court.

  • No. The mediator must remain impartial and have no connection to your dispute. The mediator does not decide the outcome and cannot dictate any particular result. Instead, the mediator’s role is to facilitate communication, assist the parties in identifying issues and joint problem solving, and explore settlement alternatives for the parties to consider to resolve the dispute.

  • Yes. Mediation is confidential and private. Only parties and their attorneys can attend mediation. Nothing you say in mediation can be disclosed or used against you later on unless required or permitted by law.

  • No. The same rules apply to in-person and virtual mediation. Virtual mediation is conducted using video conferencing and is often easier to schedule. In person mediation is usually conducted at an attorney’s office. In both types of mediation, all the parties and their attorneys are usually convened in one room (or virtual room) for a short introductory joint session. Thereafter, the parties are split into separate rooms (or virtual rooms) so they may have private conversations with the mediator who then goes back and forth between the parties to explore settlement options.

  • No. You do not need an attorney for mediation, but having competent legal representation in a legal dispute is always advisable. If you want to pursue mediation without an attorney, the first step is reaching an agreement with the other party or parties in your dispute to engage in the mediation process and select a mediator all agree to use. At that point, schedule the mediation using the “Schedule Mediation” button at top right and we will provide an agreement to mediate for all parties to sign.

  • I approach mediation from a unique perspective. Like most mediators I am an attorney who has litigated all types of civil disputes.  Unlike most mediators, however, I have spent many years starting and operating several types of businesses that from time to time became involved in legal disputes. Not only have I participated in litigation and mediation as an attorney, I have also participated in both as a party. I know from experience what it is like to de deposed, called as a witness at trial, negotiate in mediations, sit through a jury trial, carry the stress and uncertainty that goes along with litigation, and pay legal fees for months on end. Having seen litigation from various angles, I can provide parties with a unique perspective to help them best assess the risks and benefits of reaching a mediated settlement versus going to trial.

  • In general, my fee to conduct mediation is $175 per hour per party with a maximum of $575 per hour in the aggregate for all parties. Multiple persons or entities, represented by the same law firm, shall be considered a single party for these purposes. A single person or entity, represented by multiple attorneys, shall also be considered a single party for this purpose. These fees may be altered in special circumstances.

  • To schedule a mediation, click the “Schedule Mediation” button at top right. Select the appropriate option for in-person or virtual and half day or full day. Then select the date for your mediation and provide the requested information. We will contact you to confirm. If you have any questions, contact us by email at patrick@mccarthymediation.com or by phone at 850-259-9459.

Frequently Asked Questions